Preshy's Restaurant

Reviews about Preshy's Restaurant

• 5 / 5

  By Susan Peter
  I'm sorry that so many people have had negative experiences with the owner. I ate at the restaurant less than one week ago, and my experience was positive. Although I was alone, I was seated quickly, and everyone was very polite including the owner. Perhaps they are reading these reviews and getting the message.
  March 29, 2017
• 2 / 5

  By Linn McEvoy
  we have been going to Preshy's since moving here in 2010 ...the food is good, prices excellent and portions are not overly huge which we like. We have brought family, friends and even had a few celebrations there. It is close to our home so it's very convenient. We have gone there sometimes 2x in a week but at least 3 times a month. After tonight, NEVER AGAIN.
  Roberto the owner is rude. ..think "soup Nazi" you don't get parm cheese , you take it or leave it. You get it the way he serves it. Don't ask for anything different. If you pronounce something incorrectly, you can bet you will be corrected and order something simple like chicken parm and he LAUGHS AT YOU! We learned to deal with as the good outweighed the bad, but after tonight..no more. We were seated at 5pm, not many customers; we try to be early to not interfere with his ridiculous "reservation" requirement. We sat and asked if there were any special...we were told no... we ordered our food off the menu, a bottle of wine and as people started filing in we heard him tell the table behind us the special of tonight was "mussels" my husbands favorite. Well after waiting for our check, my husband asked Roberto...are we not worthy customers we don't get offered the specials? He claimed the mussels had been freshly delivered since we were seated...come ON that is ridiculous and such bull. Fact is he was in a mood and didn't offer to us specials as he has done in the past. Enjoy your success in your strip mall Roberto...your wife is far from italian and you are not in Northern Italy. You an arrogant ass in Lower Delaware. so.. go if you must but he will NEVER see these 2 local customers again.
  December 01, 2016
• 3 / 5

  By Lee Fugitt
  Good food but slow. You will def need a reservation. We were walk-ins and got lucky but the place is small and fills up quick.
  November 16, 2016
• 1 / 5

  By michael steinberg
  Just ate there 2 weeks ago and although very small portions, it was good.I was with my neighbor who introduced it to me. Last night, Nov. 5, 2016 I returned as a single and although there were at least 3 empty tables of two, he refused to seat me. He said he doesn't serve parties of one. I just drove up from my Bethany (vacation) home specifically to eat there. I'm in the area at least one or two times a month off season and constant during the summer. I'm a creature of habit and was hoping to make this a regular dining spot for myself while on business and just in general. Obviously, I will never return and side with those who criticize!
  This is not a place to take a family for fear of Roberto's behavior may offend children. His rudeness shouldn't be over looked because it's cheap to dine their. For a few bucks more, many other establishments are available. BTW, ended up at Touch Of Italy and it was great!!
  Thank you Roberto for steering me clear of Preshy's and giving me a story that I can share with others to avoid going. I did file a complaint with the BBB.
  October 16, 2016
• 1 / 5

  By Lisa Steinberg
  After previously eating at Preshy's my father decided to go back, this time he was by himself and got turned away. He was turned away because he was told "sorry my friend, I do not have tables for one", even though he had 3 open tables. To discriminate against someone because they are eating alone is despicable. Stay away from Preshy's and the nasty owner who does not value his customers no matter what the size of the party.
  October 14, 2016